Super Street Network

 |   |  Aston Martin DBS Volante Carbon Edition vs. Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG Roadster vs. BMW M6 Convertible - Performance Bargain

Aston Martin DBS Volante Carbon Edition vs. Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG Roadster vs. BMW M6 Convertible - Performance Bargain

When you’re looking for power and style, is price important?

Greg Emmerson
Jan 15, 2013 SHARE
Epcp 1212 01 o_DBS SLS_M5 Photo 1/11   |   EPCP-121200-DBS-054-059-

You could live pretty comfortably with $649661 in your checking account, but that’s what you’d need to blow on these three topless fantasies if you wanted to park them in your garage.

Interestingly, each is about $100k more than the next, but which represents the purest driving experience? Which is the best daily driver? Which of these could you live with if you could only choose one?

Epcp 1212 02 o_2013 aston martin DBS_volante carbon edition Photo 2/11   |   Aston Martin DBS Volante Carbon Edition vs. Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG Roadster vs. BMW M6 Convertible - Performance Bargain

When you’re looking at cars costing six-figures, it’s hard to imagine value would be part of the equation, but you wouldn’t want to buy the wrong car. You wouldn’t want to drive off in one of these knowing you had second best…

Our three-way battle royale would take place between the Aston Martin DBS Volante Carbon Edition, Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG Roadster and BMW M6 Convertible. They could be scored on many aspects: not least the raw numbers. But for us, driving pleasure is the overriding factor. So if you plan a route according to the most entertaining roads, rather than the shortest distance, you think like us.

We could only secure these three temptresses for a short time, so maximizing our time behind the wheel was crucial. What would we do, where would we go? We planned some epic trips, but a drive into the desert to finalize the eBay Porsche 911 (featured elsewhere in this issue) presented us with the best opportunity.

Rising at 4am, even LA’s crowded freeways would be lightly trafficked, and the desert roads would be… well, deserted.

Obviously we’d keep everything within the legal speed limit, officer, but a network of unpopulated roads seemed the answer to our prayers.

Epcp 1212 03 o_2013 aston martin DBS_volante carbon edition Photo 3/11   |   EPCP-121200-DBS-054-059-

Long stretches of freeway under 70mph can be tedious in cars that can comfortably double that number. Fortunately, each car is equipped with a semi-automatic transmission that simply requires fingers to be flexed to bring on the noise.

The seven-speed M Double Clutch Transmission in the BMW M6 is probably the most advanced, with its adjustable shift points and shift speeds, while the SLS AMG isn’t far behind. Technically, the least advanced is the Aston’s auto ’box that’s a little more ponderous, yet still unleashes the 12 hounds of hell once the V12 hits its sweet spot. So while it won’t top the nerdometer, it performs the task requested of it.

This is the overriding impression of the DBS. As soon as you look beyond the glitz and glamour of its supermodel looks, it’s clearly the product of a small company in the British Midlands. A point most vividly exemplified by the infotainment.

Yes, the DBS has a big screen on the dash like the others, but its restricted to second-party navigation duties, and the controls are a little clunky. Tune the radio or make a call and you’re down to a tiny one-line LCD screen on the radio that has you removing your eyes from the road for extended periods to decipher what it’s saying. In fact, you end up controlling music and calls from the phone, channeling everything through the car’s speakers. It works, but it isn’t the slick operator that BMW’s once-loathed iDrive system has become.

The smooth integration of nav, Bluetooth, music, apps and more into the M6 is very impressive. Navigation commands can be heard, seen on the widescreen or viewed on the heads-up display projected onto the glass in front of you.

Epcp 1212 04 o_2013 aston martin DBS volante carbon edition_engine bay Photo 4/11   |   Aston Martin DBS Volante Carbon Edition vs. Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG Roadster vs. BMW M6 Convertible - Performance Bargain

Controls are input through the iDrive, steering wheel or sometimes the console buttons. Every discipline has multiple inputs and displays, each repeating similar steps to give the driver the option that suits him best. Yet there isn’t an overload, it’s simple and intuitive. Who thought we’d say that about BMW’s interface five years ago?

Where BMW has reduced its switchgear and clutter to a minimum, the SLS looks like Mercedes went to a clearance sale at Radio Shack: there are buttons in every crevice, with slightly confusing symbols that don’t make the functions immediately apparent. Adjusting the seat was a good example of this proliferation of control surfaces, with two adjustment buttons tucked under the front of the seat, while others were on the side. Both the BMW and Aston were more logical to use than the Merc.

With familiarity, operating the SLS would undoubtedly become instinctive, yet it still seems you’d spend a lot of time with your eyes off the road, scanning the myriad of buttons to find the correct function. The SLS cabin felt techie but was also slightly overwhelming.

The Noise

The cool, crisp 4am air seemed to be shaped like a megaphone, amplifying the exhaust note from each of these machines, each with very different powerplants.

The BMW has very clever turbos: two twin-scroll turbines, perched between the reverse-flow cylinder heads; the exhaust valves placed on the inside, feeding the crossflow manifold to reduce lag and increase torque. However, they inevitably absorb some of that sound energy that would otherwise let the 560hp 4.4L V8 resemble an angry Nascar. Revving to 7200rpm, it’s tame by BMW M standards but when pushed to the limit, the V8 has a menacing snarl. It brings another facet to the M6’s otherwise laidback character that would make you think twice about feeding it by hand if it were a dog.

Epcp 1212 05 o_2013 mercedes benz SLS_AMG roadster Photo 5/11   |   EPCP-121200-DBS-054-059-

That said, in this company, it was the ginger-haired stepchild. Whether the DBS or SLS sounds the best is open to debate. On a 2-1 vote, the Benz came out on top for its sheer ferocity and surprising volume, heightened by the silent morning breeze.

My vote went to the Aston. The V12 has a different character, less mechanical but more operatic. It’s higher pitched, not as rich as the Merc’s V8 but seemingly more exotic. It’s F1 vs stockcar, so take your pick.

The SLS 6.2L V8 appeals to your primitive nature, the V12 is more cultured, but both were spine-tingling in the tunnels we passed through.

The same characteristics applied to each car’s performance: The BMW was slightly muted here; the Benz was raw; while the Aston needed you to dig to find it.

It was almost as if you had to qualify to unlock the treasures buried inside the DBS. I have to admit my first experience was terrifying. Having obtained extra insurance for what was the most expensive road car I’d ever driven, I signed several forms and headed for the rush hour freeway. Ordinarily, I’m a swordsmith, slicing my path through multiple lanes to defeat dozing drivers who pick a lane and remain in it for the duration.

Epcp 1212 06 o_2013 mercedes benz SLS_AMG roadster Photo 6/11   |   EPCP-121200-DBS-054-059-

In the DBS, what previously appeared like a chess game became a deadly obstacle course. Sudden lane changes, unexpected braking, drivers moving closer to take a look; the freeway was a minefield, and the snatchy carbon-ceramic brakes weren’t helping. Light pressure for more than a second or two would build into heavy braking without any extra leg effort. Then jumping back on the gas to avoid traffic piling into the gorgeous rear would be similarly staccato as it hesitated, kicked down, then shot off towards the closely spaced traffic.

It took a while to gather my senses, anticipate the brake pedal and select the transmission’s Sport mode so it would hold a gear, becoming more responsive to the throttle.

The next day, on an empty stretch of road, I paddled down a couple of cogs and let the 510hp V12 sing. It was as if the few cars around me had jumped on the brakes as they dwindled in the rearview mirror.

Once you relaxed, the Aston seemed to wrap its arms around you. The transmission, although not a newer double-clutch, was the only one you could park easily – the other two requiring stabs of throttle and brake to overcome the stall speed.

The suspension settings were superb. The Comfort mode absorbed everything; it was like riding in a very low limousine, but even in Sport mode it was surprising well damped, with good roll control. Allied to its supportive seats, it proved a remarkably comfortable grand tourer.

Epcp 1212 07 o_2013 mercedes benz SLS_AMG roadster Photo 7/11   |   EPCP-121200-DBS-054-059-

The Mercedes-Benz, on the other hand, was significantly tauter. Its engine response was more instantaneous, thanks in part to a more intelligent transmission and lower weight. It seemed more inclined to follow your commands and, where the DBS felt like a high-maintenance supermodel, the SLS was a bit more down ’n dirty.

From the second you fired what’s easily one of the most abrasive, intimidating exhaust notes of all time, you just want to go fast. Very fast. With 563hp on tap, this car feels stupid quick. Floor it for 3.8sec and you’re doing 60mph, and in another 8.2sec you’ve covered the quarter-mile and accelerating past 120mph, seemingly with less effort than it takes to secure the seatbelt.

Compared to the DBS and M6, the SLS feels slightly less refined, a bit rabid dog. Something you wouldn’t put a small child in the passenger seat.

There’s a “comfort” suspension setting in the Merc but its definition is like suggesting skydiving is relaxing. And while the Roadster is a bit too stiff, it deserves this connection to the black-top, especially at triple-digit speeds where it can feel a little fidgety but gets the job done.

SHARE ARTICLE

With the driver aids extinguished, the SLS is a handful. It’ll spin its rear tires in first, second and third gear if you’re brutal. It will even drift with only a slight mid-corner blip in fourth gear, because there’s always an abundance of low-end grunt.

Epcp 1212 08 o_2013 BMW M6 convertible_engine bay Photo 8/11   |   Aston Martin DBS Volante Carbon Edition vs. Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG Roadster vs. BMW M6 Convertible - Performance Bargain

Like the Aston, the car is a masterpiece in the sense that most masterpieces have flaws. Neither is perfect and yet the positive attributes of these insanely powerful, stunningly gorgeous cars are so good you can forgive the poor dash layout, woeful fuel economy and impracticality.

Such factors are quickly forgotten when you’re behind the wheel on an empty road, the window down and all you have is the exhaust note and your nerve to get you to the other end.

By comparison, the 560hp, 4.2sec,155mph BMW M6 was overwhelmed by these divas. Even with its satin silver paint job and concave black-chromed wheels, it’s clearly not going to win the beauty prize. It’s a handsome car, with its sucked-in curves and deep spoilers, but it won’t be the one going home with the winner’s sash in this company.

Part of the problem is its weight. At 4500 lb it’s portly, if remarkably rigid. However, it has to carry an extra 900 lb more than the SLS from corner to corner, demanding more of its acceleration, braking and overall grip.

Where the M6 scored was in comfort and practicality. It’s a car that draws less attention, offers more space, more accessible technology, and more accessible performance. With 500 lb-ft of torque available from 1500-5750rpm, the twin-turbo motor is very tractable, and its multifaceted transmission can be set just how you want it: mild or wild, to match your mood.

When faced with the price of the other two vehicles, the M6 was the logical choice of the bunch. It would be equally as good for a weekend getaway with your lady, as a blast down through your favorite canyon. It’s even great in traffic.

Epcp 1212 09 o_2013 BMW M6 convertible_m badge Photo 9/11   |   Aston Martin DBS Volante Carbon Edition vs. Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG Roadster vs. BMW M6 Convertible - Performance Bargain

Despite its chunky disadvantage, the M6 appeared almost as fast as the SLS in a straight line, and had a slight advantage over the Aston.

BMW found a way to make the M6 really handle, but driven in convoy with these sports cars you were fully aware of the ballast being lugged around each corner.

Costing almost half as much as the SLS and one-third of the DBS, the M6 wasn’t a car we expected to live in this realm. And yet it did. It could stay in touch with both of them on almost any road while being far less expensive to buy, service and run.

Unfortunately, when picking teams it would be the one left on the sideline until last. When grabbing the keys, they were the ones left for the slower witted. Getting behind the wheel was like taking one for the team. Yet once you got underway, the M6 didn’t seem like a punishment.

Perhaps predictably, the BMW finished in last place. To be honest, it was set up for failure. How could it compete with these supercars? And yet, it’s a winner because not only could it compete on the road but it defeated the opposition in terms of everyday practicality.

Epcp 1212 10 o_2013 BMW M6_convertible Photo 10/11   |   EPCP-121200-DBS-054-059-

Buying the M6 would be the smart move, the intelligent choice. However, you don’t buy a convertible sports car with the right side of your brain; it’s an emotional decision based on imperceptibles.

Put to the vote, the SLS was our favorite 2-1 for its visceral appeal. It’s unearthly engine note won a lot of fans, the acres of flat-silver hood, the tight proportions and the racecar handling.

The remaining vote was mine: the deciding vote, in this instance. I gave it to the Aston, partly because it isn’t perfect, partly because I could forgive it almost anything.

Anything that looks this good has to go to the top of the pile but, more importantly, the car makes you feel special.

It’s a cliché, but you feel like 007. The DBS Volante Carbon Edition brings an element of theatre to every journey. People wave at you or stop to talk, drivers come in for a closer look. But that’s not why it’s special, that simply confirms the feel-good factor is shared by everybody.

Yes, the electronics are dated, there’s not much luggage space, and it’s damn thirsty when using all 12 cylinders hard. However, the DBS works in harmony with you. It doesn’t fight you, the suspension isn’t trying to bounce you off the road, there aren’t lots of distractions to take you away from the mission at hand.

Put it in D, select comfort mode and wind your way home. Or pull back on the shift paddle, select Sport and have some old-fashioned fun in a chassis that communicates what’s happening to the front wheels and the rear.

Epcp 1212 11 o_DBS SLS_M5 Photo 11/11   |   Aston Martin DBS Volante Carbon Edition vs. Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG Roadster vs. BMW M6 Convertible - Performance Bargain

In my mind, the SLS felt clinical in comparison, the M6 a little ordinary. Yet we’re only talking fractions, and each will perform most tasks with relish. But if you want every journey to feel cinematic, and you don’t mind what it costs, the Aston Martin DBS is the car for that task.

Spec 2013 Aston Martin DBS Volante Carbon Edition 2013 Mercedes-benz SLS AMG Roadster 2013 BMW M6 Convertible
Layout Longitudinal front-engine, rear-wheel drive Longitudinal front-engine, rear-wheel drive Longitudinal front engine, rear-wheel drive
Engine 5.9L V12 DOHC 48v 6.2L V8 DOHC 32v, variable valve timing, variable intake manifold, dry sump 4.4L V8 DOHC 32v S63Tü M TwinPower bi-turbo, twin-scroll turbos, cross-bank exhaust manifold, individual throttle bodies, Valvetronic variable valve control, Double VANOS valve timing
Transmission rear-mounted Touchtronic 2 six-speed automatic AMG seven-speed Speedshift DCT rear transaxle seven-speed M Double Clutch Transmission with Drivelogic and Active M differential
Suspension double wishbone suspension, ADS adaptive damping Double wishbone suspension all-round, adaptive damping double wishbones, rigid rear subframe, Dynamic Damper Control
Brakes six-piston calipers, 15.7” rotors f, four-piston, 14.1” r six-piston calipers, 15.4” rotor f,four-piston, 14.2” r six-piston calipers, 15.7” drilled rotors f, single-piston calipers, 15.6” r
Wheels & Tires 20x8.5”, 245/35 R20 f, 20x11”, 295/30 R20 r 19x9.5”, 265/35 R19 f, 20x11”, 295/30 R20 r 19x9.5”, 265/40 ZR19 f, 19x10.5”, 295/35 ZR19 r
MSRP $302576 $198675 $113995
Performance
Peak Power 510hp @ 6500rpm 563hp @ 6800rpm 560hp @ 6000rpm
Peak Torque 420 lb-ft @ 5750rpm 479 lb-ft @ 4750rpm 500 lb-ft @ 1500-5750rpm
0-60mph 4.3sec 3.7sec 4.2sec
Top Speed 190mph 197mph 155mph
Weight 3990 lb 3661 lb 4508 lb
Economy 12/18/14mpg (city/highway/combined) 14/20/16mpg (city/highway/combined) 14/20/16mpg (city/highway/combined)

SHARE ARTICLE
By Greg Emmerson
1075 Articles

RELATED ARTICLES

BROWSE CARS BY MARKET

MORE FEATURES

Supercharged Subaru BRZ that's super clean.
Big MikeOct 20, 2014
Creating the mid-engined monster enthusiasts want from Stuttgart
Peter WuOct 19, 2014
More JDM street goodness from Hawaii
Aaron BonkOct 19, 2014
Bay Area-built Evo with all the right stuff
Aaron BonkOct 18, 2014
What happened to the birthplace of the EB110
Matt ZuchowskiOct 17, 2014

SEARCH ARTICLES BY MAKE/MODEL

Search
TO TOP